How Sales-to-Minors Violations Arise, and What Defenses Are Available

Published Read 3 min read

On this page

A sale to a minor is a crime for the person who makes it and a separate administrative case against the business’s permit. Under Section 106.03 of the Alcoholic Beverage Code, selling alcohol to anyone under 21 with criminal negligence is a Class A misdemeanor. The seller has a defense if the minor showed an apparently valid government-issued ID with a matching photo and description showing an age of 21 or older, but that defense is lost if the seller scanned the ID and the scan showed it was invalid. The business’s permit is protected separately through the safe harbor.

How the violation happens

The offense in Section 106.03 has two parts: a sale of an alcoholic beverage to a minor, and criminal negligence by the seller. In practice the sale happens at the point of service, when an employee does not ask for identification, looks at an ID without comparing it to the customer, accepts an ID that does not show an age of 21, or overrides what a scanner reports. TABC tests this directly through underage compliance operations, and its inspection rules treat certain locations licensed for less than two years that have not yet been through one as priorities.

A companion offense covers others involved. Section 106.06 makes it an offense to purchase alcohol for a minor or give it to one, and a permit can also be put at risk when a licensee permits a minor to possess or consume alcohol on the premises.

The identification defense

Section 106.03(b) says a person who sells to a minor does not commit the offense if the minor falsely represented being 21 or older by displaying proof of identification that:

  1. was apparently valid;
  2. contained a physical description and a photograph consistent with the minor’s appearance;
  3. purported to show the minor was 21 or older; and
  4. was issued by a governmental agency, such as a Texas Department of Public Safety driver’s license or identification card, a passport, or a military identification card.

All four have to be true. An ID from a private source, one with a photo that does not match, or one that shows the holder is under 21 does not qualify.

The scanning limit

Section 106.03(d) removes the defense for a person who accesses the electronically readable information on a driver’s license or identification certificate, under Section 109.61, and that information identifies the license or certificate as invalid. A seller who scans the card and ignores an invalid result cannot rely on how convincing the card looked. Scanning helps a business catch fakes, but only if staff treat an invalid result as a refusal.

Two tracks: the employee and the permit

  • The employee. The seller faces the criminal case under Section 106.03, with the identification defense available when its conditions are met.
  • The permit. TABC can pursue the business separately under Section 106.13, where a sale to a minor can bring suspension or cancellation. The business’s main protection is the safe harbor in Section 106.14, which keeps an employee’s sale from being attributed to an employer that required TABC-approved seller training, whose employee took it, and that did not encourage the violation, together with the further conditions TABC applies.

Preventing the sale

  1. Card everyone who could be under 30, or everyone, and compare the photo and description to the customer, not just the birth date.
  2. Accept only government-issued photo IDs, such as a driver’s license, state identification card, passport, or military ID, and refuse IDs that are expired, altered, or unreadable.
  3. Treat an invalid scan as a refusal, with no manager override.
  4. Watch for third-party purchases, such as an adult buying for a group that includes minors.
  5. Keep training and safe harbor records current, so an employee’s mistake does not become the permit’s violation.

This article is general information about Texas alcoholic beverage law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and TABC rules change; confirm current requirements with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission, the relevant city or county, or a licensed Texas attorney before acting.

Related posts:

  1. How Sales-to-Intoxicated-Person Violations Arise, and How They Are Contested Selling alcohol to an intoxicated person is a crime under Section 101.63 of the Alcoholic Beverage Code when the seller acts with criminal negligence, and the same sale is a......
  2. How After-Hours and Breach-of-Peace Violations Threaten a TABC Permit Selling or serving a drink after legal hours, allowing people to keep drinking after the consumption cutoff, running a premises where fights and disorder happen, and failing to report a......
  3. What Types of TABC Violations Can Put a Permit at Risk TABC sorts most violations into two families. Public safety violations, such as selling to a minor or an intoxicated person, selling after hours, or allowing a breach of the peace,......
  4. What Is a Distiller’s and Rectifier’s Permit, and What On-Site Sales Are Texas Distilleries Allowed? Three kinds of on-site sales are open to a Texas distillery, and each has its own ceiling: samples of up to half an ounce; drinks for consumption at the distillery,......
  5. How Does the Comptroller Use Pour-Cost and Depletion Analysis to Estimate Unreported Sales? A depletion analysis starts from what a permittee bought, not what it reported. The Comptroller converts the liquor, beer, and wine purchased into drinks, prices those drinks, and compares the......
  6. Which TABC Permit Fits a Restaurant, and How Does the Alcohol-to-Food Sales Ratio Drive That Choice? Texas has no single restaurant permit. A restaurant that pours spirits needs a Mixed Beverage Permit (MB); one that serves only wine and beer can operate on a Wine and......
  7. What Is the Mixed Beverage Gross Receipts Tax, and How Does It Differ from the Mixed Beverage Sales Tax? Texas taxes drinks sold under a mixed beverage permit twice. The mixed beverage gross receipts tax is 6.7 percent of the permittee's receipts from alcoholic drinks and the ice and......
  8. How can an FB certificate remove the 51% firearms sign-posting requirement depending on the alcohol sales ratio? A Food and Beverage Certificate (FB) removes the 51% sign requirement outright. The statute that requires the sign, Section 411.204 of the Texas Government Code, says in its own words......
  9. What Hours-of-Sale Rules, Including Sunday Sales, Govern Different Permit Types? Texas sale hours depend on what is being sold and under which permit. Bars and restaurants serving mixed drinks may sell from 7 a.m. to midnight Monday through Saturday and......
  10. How does an FB certificate enable to-go and delivery alcohol sales alongside food? For a restaurant or bar holding a Mixed Beverage Permit (MB), the Food and Beverage Certificate (FB) is the condition that unlocks to-go and delivery alcohol. Section 28.1001 of the......
  11. Griffith & Hughes PLLC, TABC Licensing and Alcohol Law A Texas law firm focused exclusively on TABC licensing and alcohol law. At a Glance Firm Griffith & Hughes PLLC (formerly Griffith Firm) Focus Texas Alcoholic…...
  12. Which Alcohol Permits Apply to Convenience Stores and Gas Stations Selling Beer and Wine? A convenience store or gas station that sells beer and wine to go needs one of two Texas off-premise retail authorizations. The Wine and Malt Beverage Retailer's Off-Premise Permit (BQ)......
  13. What Should a Written Alcohol Policy Contain to Protect a Permit Holder? A written alcohol policy protects a permit only if it covers the decisions that create violations, such as checking identification, recognizing and refusing intoxicated customers, and training staff, and if......
  14. How a TABC Violation Is Defended at a SOAH Hearing At a State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) hearing, TABC usually carries the burden of proving the violation by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning more likely than not, and......
  15. What Is an L-Cert (Certificate of Local Compliance), and Why Does TABC Require It Before Issuing a Permit? The L-Cert, also called the Certificate of Local Compliance, is TABC's Required Certifications form (Form L-CERT): the set of sign-offs that new license and permit applications carry. In it, the......

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *